Post Count: 5/10
Member Count: 7/10
Skin and Images: 5/10
Layout: 3/10
Administration: 7/10
Moderation: 7/10
Member Activity: /10
Originality: 3/10
Overall: 5/10
Additional Notes: Alright, first off all, I saw this forum a few times passing by. And everytime I get annoyed by how streched out the skin is, and how ugly that looks. I'm guessing it has to do with the banner...and yeah, then there's the banner. The banner isn't high quality. A banner will say allot for a forum, and I think banners are pretty important for HP forums as well. The banner is almost the first thing a guest
* ShinLimber will get to see. Also the images used in the forum descriptions arent really appealing to me, and I get a 'cheap' feeling from them.
Maybe a tip for the buttons from the topsites, instead of having them in the header, place them in the footer, so they'll appear beneath your statistics box.
The first Catagory has simple to much forums in it, it looks messy. Try to get some as subforums, or get half of them in a new catagory. Then going down the forum, there you have catagorys with only 1/2 forums inside of it. Catagory's, to look good, should at least have 3 forums in them. Also the ordering of your forums is confuzing.
I"m a big HP fan, but this isn't a forum that appeals to me at all. Work on the forum layout/appearance, and it'll become allot better ^^